2 Catholic bishops at odds over Biden receiving Communion – Cleveland, Ohio

Cleveland, Ohio 2021-05-10 07:08:05 –

(AP) — They share Roman Catholicism as faith and California as their home. Still, there is a deep gap between Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone of San Francisco and Bishop Robert McElroy of San Diego in the high-stakes debate about whether politicians who support the right to abortion should be denied communion. There is.

Cordileone, who has long established himself as a powerful anti-abortion activist, has recently been identified by such politicians. President Joe Biden Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi — Because of their position on this issue, they should not be communed.Archbishop Pastoral letter We strengthened our message on the topic of May 1st in a one-hour interview with Catholic TV network EWTN on Friday.

“I would say to those who advocate abortion,’This is a murder. Stop the murder. You are in a position to do something about it,” he told the interviewer.

In neither the letter nor the interview, Cordileone did not mention Pelosi, the representative of San Francisco, by name. However, he has criticized her in the past for her attitude towards abortion, which is directly inconsistent with Catholic teaching.

McElroy, statement Published Wednesday by the Jesuit magazine America, it assassinated a campaign to exclude Biden and other like-minded Catholic officials from communion.

“It will have tremendous devastating consequences,” writes McElroy. “The Eucharist has been weaponized and deployed as a tool for political warfare. This should not happen.”

The polarized view of the two prelates, as expected, shows how likely this issue could be split before the US Catholic Bishops’ Council in Parliament starting June 16. The doctrine should draft a document stating that Biden and other Catholic officials with similar views on abortion should refrain from communion.

In accordance with existing USCCB policies, such documents may leave decisions regarding the withholding of communion to individual bishops.

Biden, the second Catholic president of the United States, regularly attends masses and worships at his homes in Wilmington, Delaware, and Washington.

Cardinal Wilton Gregory, Archbishop of Washington, has revealed that Biden welcomes the acceptance of communion in his church. Bishop William König, appointed as the head of the Diocese of Wilmington on April 30, said he would be happy to talk to Biden about his view of abortion, but as König’s predecessor did, he was communion. He did not say whether he would allow him to continue to receive the communion.

Biden is unlikely to hear the call to abandon communion, but the USCCB document urging him to do so would still be a noteworthy rebuke.

In his idyllic letter, Cordileone writes that it is the responsibility of the Catholic priest to “correct the Catholics who mistakenly and sometimes stubbornly promote abortion.”

Initially, Cordileone wrote that this rebuke should take place in a personal conversation between the “wrong Catholic” and his or her priest or bishop.

“Since we are dealing with public examples of cooperation in public figures and moral evil, this amendment can also take the form of public exclusion from the acceptance of communion,” he wrote. .. “This is a bitter drug, but the seriousness of the evil of abortion can justify it.”

In the 2020 presidential election, Catholic voters split the vote almost evenly between Biden and Republican Donald Trump. National polls consistently show that the majority of Catholics in the United States believe that abortion should be legal, at least in some cases.

If Biden was excluded from communion, McElroy wrote: “Half of the Catholics in the United States see this action as a faction in nature, which will bring the horrific division of the faction that has plagued our country into the very act of worship. God is our oneness. Was intended to cause and mean. “

McElroy also wondered why abortion was the comprehensive focus of some bishops, even though the crime of racism was not noticeable in their comments.

“It would be impossible to convince many Catholics in our country that this omission did not result from the desire to limit the impact of exclusion on the public leaders of democracy.” McKelroy wrote.

Towards the end of his statement, McElroy quoted Pope Francis as saying that communion was “not a prize for perfection, but a powerful medicine and nutrition for the weak.”

Cordileone sought to explain the timing in an addendum to his idyllic letter.

“I’ve been working on this idyllic letter for a long time, but I don’t want to publish it during the election to avoid further confusion among those who misunderstand it as” politicizing “the issue. It was, “he wrote. “No matter which party is in power at a particular moment, we all need to consider some basic truths and moral principles.”

The Associated Press’s religious coverage is supported by Lilly Endowment through The Conversation US. AP is solely responsible for this content.

2 Catholic bishops at odds over Biden receiving Communion Source link 2 Catholic bishops at odds over Biden receiving Communion

Back to top button