Nashville-Davidson

DA’s office wants couple convicted of child rape and murder exonerated – Nashville-Davidson, Tennessee

Nashville-Davidson, Tennessee 2021-12-03 18:19:41 –

Nashville, Tennessee (WKRN) – The District Attorney’s Office for Davidson County states that couples convicted of child rape and murder in 1987 are innocent and should be overturned.

Joyce Watkins and her late boyfriend Charlie Dunn spent 27 years in prison.

Watkins’ 4-year-old nephew lived with his family in 1987. When Watkins and her boyfriend picked up the child, they noticed signs of physical and sexual trauma. Watkins took her to the hospital, where the girl was placed in a life support system and died the next day. Watkins and Dan were then put in jail and convicted the following year.

For decades, the couple maintained their innocence. On Friday, Judge Angelita Blackshare Dalton heard the evidence behind these allegations.

“Are you innocent of these sins?” The prosecutor asked Joyce Watkins. “Yes, that’s right. Yes. Yes. Yes.”

Watkins, now 74, is asking the court to prove not only her name, but also the name of her boyfriend Charlie Dunn at the time.

“Did Charlie do anything to harm Brandy?” Asked the prosecutor. “Number. No, no,” Watkins replies.

The Tennessee Innocence Project and the prosecutor of the Conviction Examination Unit, established under District Attorney General Glenn Funk, alleged that misrepresentation of evidence to the jury led to Dan and Watkins’ 1987 tort. ing.

“It’s a circumstantial case based solely on false medical testimony,” says Funk.

Adele Luis, Tennessee’s chief coroner, found that the state’s then deputy coroner, Dr. Gretel Harlan, made false findings, even though he used the wrong medical terminology in his autopsy report. I testified.

“Is there any medical evidence to support her opinion on the timeline?” Ask the lawyer. “No,” Lewis replies.

“Is there any medical evidence that these injuries happened while the child was caring for Joyce Watkins or Shirley Dunn?” Lewis replies “no” again.

At the time of the trial, Gretel Harlan was married to then-chief coroner Dr. Charles Harlan.
He approved the report. Charles was later convicted of 20 illegal acts and his doctor’s license was permanently revoked in 2005.

“We can’t give justice to these people, but we can admit what happened to them and finally reveal their names,” the prosecutor told the court. Told.

A family member, including the girl’s mother, who said in News 2 “I hope the results are great,” attended the hearing.

While waiting for the elevator, she could hear her say: We never believed they did anything. “

Find other top stories on wkrn.com

Judge Angelita Blackshare Dalton will review the evidence presented on Friday and decide whether to revoke the conviction “hopefully really soon”.

News 2 sought comment from then-Davidson County District Attorney General Tory Johnson. He sent the following statement:

“I am not familiar with the details of this proceeding or the allegations that the defendant is innocent in reality, so I cannot comment on or answer the questions raised. Such cases are time. Apparently, this case is particularly difficult due to the course of the proceedings, fading of memory, the death of defendants, witnesses and other participants, lack of clear evidence such as DNA, and other factors. There have been many changes since being investigated and attempted to constantly improve the system and prevent illegal convictions, but there is no perfect system. In fact, if this case is misdetermined, it will be corrected. Should be, but I am not in a position to express my opinion. “

Former Davidson County District Attorney General Tory Johnson

DA’s office wants couple convicted of child rape and murder exonerated Source link DA’s office wants couple convicted of child rape and murder exonerated

Back to top button