Pittsburgh

DOJ closes investigation into Emmett Till killing from 1955 after failing to prove key witness lied – Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 2021-12-06 19:59:00 –

The Justice Department has officially completed its second official investigation into the infamous killing of Emmett Till without federal crime, and a potentially significant claim from one of the last living witnesses renews investigators. After leading to a search for good evidence, I left more questions. , Professor Timmothy Tyson unearthed what appears to be important evidence of the most horrific murders recorded during the Jim Crow era. She was over 60 years ago, but after a thorough investigation, the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Department concluded that she couldn’t prove that the woman lied to a federal agent about her story, CNN said. After reporting the progress of the case at the beginning of Monday, the Department of Justice subsequently released a memo explaining the evidence examined by the investigators and why the problem was resolved without federal crime. 14-Old Till, a black teen from Chicago, visited his family in Mississippi in 1955. It is a scene of a fateful encounter with Carolyn Brian Donam, who was 20 years old at the time. Witnesses claimed to whistle to Donam as Till left the market he was running with her husband, although the explanation for the day was different. Donham later testified in 1955 that Till grabbed her hand and hip and suggested her by saying she was with a “formerly white woman.” But when the testimony of the trial was raised in a 2008 interview a few years later, Tyson claimed that Donam had told him “that part is not true.” The Justice Department has already reviewed the case once and concluded in 2007 that it was not possible to prosecute at the federal level based on the evidence available and that the restriction law had long been gone. Armed with Tyson’s new allegations, federal agents once said the investigation was familiar, the goal was whether Donam actually withdrew his previous testimony in an interview with Tyson, and if so, shed light on her. It was to provide other evidence that could be guessed. “It would be in direct conflict with both her testimony in the 1955 state proceedings and the statement filed with the FBI during the previous investigation,” the Justice Department said in a memo on Monday. However, when asked directly, Donam categorically denied to investigators that she had withdrawn her testimony. And other investigators came across additional evidence: The most abominable statement Tyson returned to Donam was neither recorded nor transcribed, and he told authorities whether the record had ever been made. The agency said it had issued an inconsistent statement. Tyson took some notes about their conversation, but did not provide a solid timeline of when her confessions were reported to have happened. The Justice Department said on Monday that it lied to the FBI, noting that DOJ’s lawyers did not necessarily suggest that they believed in her original story. A Justice Ministry memo continued Donam’s original explanation of what happened inside the store, but said “no witnesses could call the government to disprove her explanation.” “My report is solid,” Tyson said in a statement to CNN. “Carolin Bryant denies it and avoids talking about it as if it were a plague. I look at it based on solid evidence and tell the truth and stand in the public square. The explanation is different, but my memory has faded and most witnesses have died. The actual measure of accountability in this case has avoided federal prosecutors for decades. Till was kidnapped, tortured and killed by two white men who were charged in state court and acquitted by a white jury. The man later admitted to being killed in an interview with Look magazine and is now dead. Donam couldn’t immediately ask for comment. This latest chapter in the infamous case could leave more questions than answers to the rest of Till’s family. The unforgettable photo of his severed body, first published in Jet Magazine at the request of his mother, was imprinted on many as a lasting image of racist violence of the era. .. Kristen Clark flew to Chicago on Monday to explain directly to the rest of Till’s family what the investigators had found and the decision to end the case. I got justice. ” Till’s cousin Olly Gordon said. “We still have to move forward so that these particular hate crimes don’t continue and justice isn’t found.”

The Justice Department has officially closed Research For the infamous killing Emmett Till Only more questions were left without a second federal crime, after a potentially significant claim from one of the last living witnesses led the investigator to a new search for evidence.

In 2017, Professor Timmothy Tyson unearthed what appears to be important evidence of the most horrific murders recorded during the Jim Crow era. She makes progress over 60 years ago.

However, after a thorough investigation, the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Department concluded that it could not prove that the woman lied to a federal agent about her story.

After CNN reported the progress of the case at the beginning of Monday, the department subsequently announced Memo Explain the evidence examined by the investigators and why they resolved the problem without federal crime.

Till, a 14-year-old black teen from Chicago, visited a family in Mississippi in 1955. It is a scene of a fateful encounter with Carolyn Brian Donam, who was 20 years old at the time. Witnesses claimed to whistle to Donam as Till left the market he was running with her husband, although the explanation for the day was different. Donham later testified in 1955 that Till grabbed her hand and hip and suggested her by saying she was with a “formerly white woman.” But when the testimony of the trial was raised in a 2008 interview a few years later, Tyson claimed that Donam had told him: “That part is not true.”

Betman via CNN

Emmett Till

The explosively reported confessions triggered a major fire calling on authorities to resume the cold case. The Justice Department has already reviewed the case once and concluded in 2007 that it was not possible to prosecute at the federal level based on the evidence available and that the statute of limitations had expired.

Armed with Tyson’s new allegations, federal agents spoke to Donam again.

According to sources familiar with the investigation, the goal is whether Donam actually withdrew his previous testimony in an interview with Tyson, and if so, other things that could shed light on her role in the killings. It was to provide proof. In identifying others who may be held liable.

“It would be in direct conflict with both her testimony in the 1955 state minutes and the statement she made to the FBI during the last investigation,” the Justice Department said in a memo on Monday.

However, when asked directly, Donam categorically denied to investigators that she had withdrawn her testimony.

And other researchers ran into the problem of additional evidence.

The most abominable statement Tyson attributed to Donam was neither recorded nor transcribed, and he issued an inconsistent statement to authorities as to whether the record had ever been made, the agency said. .. Tyson took some notes about their conversation, but did not provide a solid timeline about when her confession happened.

“These facts go beyond prima facie suspicion that she withdrew her previous testimony when talking to Tyson, and therefore she lied to the FBI when she denied that. It will prevent the government from proving that, “the ministry wrote on Monday. Note that the DOJ lawyer did not necessarily suggest that she believed in her original story.

“There remains considerable doubt about the reliability of (Donham’s) original explanation of what happened in the store,” DOJ’s memo continued.

But “no witnesses can now be called by the government to disprove her account.”

When asked to comment by email, Tyson made a long statement in support of his story.

“My report is solid,” Tyson said in a statement to CNN. “Carolin Bryant denies it and avoids talking about it as if it were a plague. I look at it based on solid evidence and tell the truth and stand in the public square. “

Accounts are different, but memories have faded and most witnesses have died. The actual measurement of accountability in this case has missed federal prosecutors for decades. Till was kidnapped, tortured and killed by two white men who were charged in state court and acquitted by a white jury.The man later admitted the killing in an interview look Magazine and now dead.

Donham wasn’t immediately asked for comment.

This latest chapter in the infamous case could leave more questions than answers to the rest of Till’s family. The unforgettable photo of his severed body, first published in Jet Magazine at the request of his mother, was imprinted on many as a lasting image of racist violence of the era. ..

Justice ministry officials, including Kristen Clark, head of the civil rights department, flew to Chicago on Monday to explain directly to the rest of Till’s family what the investigators found and the decision to end the case. ..

“I can’t stop even if I don’t feel like I’ve got justice,” said Olly Gordon, one of Till’s cousins. “We still have to move forward so that these particular hate crimes don’t continue and justice isn’t found.”

DOJ closes investigation into Emmett Till killing from 1955 after failing to prove key witness lied Source link DOJ closes investigation into Emmett Till killing from 1955 after failing to prove key witness lied

Back to top button