Kansas City

Facebook board upholds Trump ban, just not an indefinite one | Politics – Kansas City, Missouri

Kansas City, Missouri 2021-05-05 12:06:38 –

Former President Donald Trump will never return to Facebook — at least not yet.

Four months after Facebook suspended Trump’s account for inciting violence that led to the deadly parliamentary riots on January 6, the company’s quasi-independent oversight committee upheld the ban. However, he told Facebook that the “indefinite” ban on the former president was unreasonable and told him to specify how long they would last. The ruling, which gives Facebook six months of compliance, effectively postpones the possibility of Trump’s return and makes the decision responsible. I will honestly return to the company.

That could put Facebook in the worst of all possible worlds-Trump supporters continue to rage at the ban, his critics push for broader social media regulation, and the company oversees He stuck to a serious problem that the Commission clearly wanted to resolve.

Jonathan Greenblatt, head of the Defamation League, said the decision was only to “kick the can” and emphasized the need for increased government oversight of social platforms.

The board decided that it was correct to suspend Trump’s account four months ago, alleging that Facebook instigated the violence that led to the deadly January 6 parliamentary riot. However, the company said it made a mistake by applying a vague penalty and passing a question to the board about whether to ban Trump permanently.

“This kind of indefinite penalty does not pass the international odor test,” said Michael McConnell, co-chair of the Supervisory Board, in a conference call with reporters. “We are not police officers, we dominate the realm of social media.”

In a statement, Trump did not directly mention the decision, but stated that the actions taken by Facebook, Twitter and Google were “total shame and embarrassment for our country.” “These corrupt social media companies have to pay a political price,” he added.

The board agreed with Facebook that two of Trump’s January 6 posts “gravely violated” both Facebook and Instagram content standards. “We love you. You are so special,” he told the mob in his first post. Second, he called them “great patriots” and told them, “I remember this day forever.”

The board justified the suspension, saying it violated Facebook’s rules for praising and supporting those involved in violence. Specifically, the board quoted Facebook’s rules for “dangerous individuals and organizations.” It bans anyone who declares a violent mission and bans postings that express their support or admiration for these people or groups.

However, the company argued that it needed to be responsible for that decision.

“Facebook will have to permanently invalidate Trump’s account or impose a suspension for a certain period of time,” said former Danish Prime Minister Helle Thorning Schmidt, Co-Chair.

The board said that if Facebook decides to restore Trump’s account, it must be able to respond quickly to further breaches. Among other recommendations, we advised not to make a clear distinction between political leaders and other influential users, as anyone with a large audience can pose a risk of serious harm. ..

Facebook has long straddled the problem, giving politicians more room than regular users. Because he argued that it was important for the public to hear even their rule-violating statements.

Facebook has created a watch panel to manage nasty content on the platform in response to widespread criticism of the issues of responding to false information, malicious language, and malicious impact campaigns quickly and effectively. Earlier decisions by the board (nine before Wednesday) tended to favor freedom of expression rather than content restrictions.

The board, which has 20 members and will eventually grow to 40, did not reveal how it voted for Trump’s suspension. A few members emphasized that Facebook should require users seeking a return after the outage to “recognize their misconduct and promise to comply with the rules in the future.”

This decision affects not only Trump, but also tech companies, world leaders, and people across the political spectrum. Many have fiercely conflicting views on the proper role of tech companies when it comes to regulating online speech and protecting people from abuse and misinformation. ..

After years of dealing with Trump’s inflammatory rhetoric with a light touch, Facebook and Instagram took a dramatic step in January to silence his account. Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg said when he announced an unprecedented move, the risk of allowing Trump to continue using the platform was too great.

“The shocking events of the last 24 hours have left President Donald Trump in office to undermine the peaceful and legitimate transfer of power to his elected successor, Joe Biden. It clearly shows that he intends to use the period, “Zuckerberg wrote on his Facebook page in January. 7.

The day before the Supervisory Board’s decision was announced, Trump published a new blog on his personal website, “From Donald J. Trump’s Desk.” This page contains a dramatic video that claims “the light of freedom rises” and praises “a place to speak freely and safely”, but this page is elsewhere on the website. It is just a display of Trump’s recent statement available. It was easy to share on Facebook and Twitter, the platforms that banished him after the riots.

Locked out of social media, Trump has embraced other platforms to deliver his message. He frequently interviewed friendly media outlets and emailed a series of statements to reporters through his official office and political parties.

Mr. Trump even says he prefers to speak over previous tweets, often describing them as more “elegant.”


This story has been amended to note that the board does not endorse Trump’s permanent ban.


The Associated Press writer Jill Corbin of Washington and David Kleper of Providence, Rhode Island contributed to the story.

Copyright 2021 AP communication. all rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.

Facebook board upholds Trump ban, just not an indefinite one | Politics Source link Facebook board upholds Trump ban, just not an indefinite one | Politics

Back to top button