Investigation of Claims from Last Trump-Biden Debate-Twin Cities

2020-10-22 23:30:54 –

Washington (AP) — President Donald Trump and Democratic challenger Joe Biden spared Thursday in their final presidential debate, hoping to shake undecided voters in the November 3 elections.

Let’s see how their remarks from Nashville, Tennessee overlap with the facts.


Trump: “All he’s doing is talking about shutdowns, but forget about him. His Democratic Governor Cuomo in New York, you see what’s happening in California and you Look at Pennsylvania, North Carolina. Democrats — All Democrats. They are shut down very tightly and they are dying. “

Biden: “Look at the states where the coronavirus is booming. They are the red states. They are the Midwestern states or the Midwestern upper states. There is a significant spike here.”

Fact: Neither is correct. Coronavirus is neither a red state problem nor a blue state problem. It’s a public health problem that affects humans, no matter where they live or what politics is.

In some Republican-led states that reopened soon, virus cases surged in the summer and are still struggling to reduce infection rates. The test positive rate in Florida is currently around 12%, indicating that this level is widespread. South Dakota is approaching 35%.

Democratic-led states like New York, which were hit hard by the first wave, were closed and virus infection rates fell to very low levels. However, they are currently seeing rebounds in certain local communities, encouraging them to target new restrictions.

Nevada and Pennsylvania are two states that have Democratic governors and currently have high transmission rates of 20% and 10%, respectively, based on a 14-day trend.


Trump: Wind turbine smoke “kills all birds” and emits more “smoke” than natural gas.

Fact: Not so. “Wind turbines (with rare exceptions) do not emit emissions that can pollute air or water and do not require water for cooling,” the US Department of Energy said.

“The most comprehensive and statistically sound estimate shows that 140,000 to 500,000 birds die annually from turbine collisions,” said the United States Fish and Wildlife Service. It also says that a collision with a building kills 599 million birds annually, hits a communications tower and kills 6.6 million birds annually, and hits a car or other vehicle, killing 214 million birds annually. It is


Trump: The Paris Agreement said, “We had to spend trillions of dollars … They suffered a great disadvantage. They intended to rob us of our business.”

Fact: The Paris Agreement, an international agreement aimed at stopping global temperature rise, is based on voluntary emission reductions. No country was forced to do anything.


“They are very well cared for and in a very clean facility,” Trump said of the children separated from their parents at the US-Mexico border.

Fact: That’s wrong.

Border guard facilities remained filthy during the height of the 2018 separation, according to Watchdog’s report and a federal attorney at law managing the care of children in immigration camps. Immigrants have become cramped far beyond their capacity. Long-term facilities for adults and children have reached capacity. That is, the administration kept people at small border stations for much longer than the 72 hours normally permitted by law.

The station is not intended for long-term care. The children were not served hot meals and the family slept on the floor on Mylar’s blanket. The flu and illness were widespread, and hundreds of small children were kept together without proper care.


Mr. Trump said of immigrants who have been released from detention in the United States and are waiting for proceedings to be granted. “They say they’re back. Less than 1% have returned. To find them … we have to send border guards.”

Fact: That’s wrong. There are far fewer immigration hearings among those released awaiting proceedings. According to Justice Department statistics, the majority will be back for the hearing.


Biden: “He’s talking about the poor boys. The last time I stood here, I told them to get up and get ready. Loosely. This guy is the same as the foghorn I have a dog whistle about the size. “

Fact: That’s not what Trump said, nor is it the name of the neo-fascist group.

In a previous debate, on September 29, Trump was asked if he would blame white supremacists and militia groups who appeared in several protests in the United States. He said, “Tell me your name,” and Biden referred to “the proud boys,” a group of far-right militants who appeared in protests in the Pacific Northwest.

“Proud Boys, stop and wait,” Trump said. Whether there is a material difference is arguable, but he didn’t tell them they were “ready.”


Biden: “People with private insurance will not lose insurance under my plan, and even under” Obamacare “, unless they choose to go elsewhere. did. “

Fact: He is wrong about “Obamacare”.

President Barack Obama at the time promised that if you liked health insurance, you could keep it under his affordable care law, but that didn’t happen to some. did.

When Obamacare came into force in 2014, millions lost their personal health insurance plans that no longer met the minimum legal requirements. The backlash forced the White House to offer a workaround, but it caused political damage.

Health insurance is a very complex area, and almost every action can have unintended consequences.


His tax Trump: “They keep talking about $ 750. I think this is an application fee …. Tens of millions of dollars I prepaid (income tax).” About his Chinese bank account: “I Was a businessman in 2013, but closed his account in 2015. “

Fact: Trump is not honest about his taxes.

The report by the New York Times, which obtained his tax records, contradicts his claim.

The IRS does not charge taxpayers a filing fee, but the tax filing service does. The $ 750 that Trump paid for income tax in 2016 and 2017 was paid to the federal government, not the tax filing service.

It’s not clear what Trump is talking about about tax prepayments, but what matters is what he ultimately owes to the government. Americans often deduct their income tax payments from their salaries. The Times reported that Trump has requested and received an income tax refund totaling $ 72.9 million since 2010. This was at the core of the IRS’s ongoing audit. According to The Times, the ruling against Mr. Trump could cost him more than $ 100 million.

According to Alan Garten, an attorney at Trump’s company, Trump did not close his bank account in China either. He told the Times that his account remained open, but the company’s office in China has been inactive since 2015.


Trump: “Joe got $ 3.5 million from Russia, and it came through Putin because he was very friendly with the former mayor of Moscow and it was the mayor of Moscow’s wife. , You got $ 3.5. Your family got $ 3.5 million. Someday you will have to explain why. “

Fact: There is no evidence of this. Trump mischaracterizes a recent report by Republican Senator Ron Johnson, who investigated Biden’s son Hunter and his commerce in Ukraine.

The report did not claim that Joe Biden himself received $ 3.5 million or that Russian President Vladimir Putin had anything to do with such payments. Also, the report does not claim that Hunter Biden put his money in his pocket. According to the report, the amount was paid to the investment company he co-founded. Hunter Biden’s attorney said in a statement to reporters that his client was not interested in the company and was not the founder of the company.


Trump for COVID-19 Victims in the United States: “As you know, 2.2 million modeled people were expected to die.”

Fact: This is the first line of his debate and it is wrong. Pandemic deaths in the United States were not expected to be very high.

Such extreme predictions were just a baseline if nothing was done to fight the pandemic. Doing nothing was by no means an option, and public health officials did not anticipate more than 2 million deaths.

Trump often cites numbers that seek to better understand the reality of more than 220,000 deaths and admit that they have reduced the expected mortality rate.

At a briefing on April 1, when Trump and his officials discussed an actual forecast of 100,000 to 240,000 deaths, the president wanted to keep the deaths below 100,000. “I think we’re doing better than that.” He has repeatedly moved goalposts to better show high mortality and infection numbers.


Trump: “We’re rounding the turn. We’re turning the corner. It’s gone.”

Fact: No, the coronavirus does not go away. Return. New cases are increasing towards the peak of summer. The death toll is also increasing.

According to data from Johns Hopkins University up to October 21, the 7-day moving average of daily new cases in the United States exceeded 42,300 on October 7 in the past two weeks to October 21. It has risen to nearly 60,000.

According to Johns Hopkins University data up to October 21, the 7-day moving average of daily new deaths in the United States has risen from 695 on October 7 to 757 on October 21 in the past two weeks. ..


Associated Press writers Cal Woodward, Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar, Seth Borenstein, Colleen Long, Eric Tucker, Josh Boak, Stephen Braun, Michael Balsamo, Hope Yen, Amanda Seitz and David Klepper contributed to this report.


Editor’s Note — See the credibility of politicians’ claims.


Find AP Fact Checks at http://apnews.com/APFactCheck

Follow @APFactCheck on Twitter: https: //twitter.com/APFactCheck

Source link

Back to top button