Migrants Not Responsible for Latest COVID-19 Surge – Atlanta, Georgia

Atlanta, Georgia 2021-10-11 10:27:20 –

Infectious disease experts say that low vaccination rates, resistance to protective measures such as wearing masks, and highly infectious delta mutations are driving the current surge in COVID-19 cases in the United States. It states.

However, many Republicans have criticized the Biden administration for the rise of immigrants, some of whom are COVID-19 positive, and many Americans, especially unvaccinated Republicans, clearly have these immigrants. We believe that we are driving the proliferation of COVID-19 in the country.

NS Recent survey According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, 55% of Republicans say that “immigrants and tourists bring COVID-19 to the United States” is “the main reason why there are so many cases of COVID-19 in the United States today.” ..

40% in unvaccinated adults It is listed “Immigrants and tourists bringing COVID-19 to the United States” are boosting the number of cases of COVID-19.

Consider that some Republican rhetoric, such as Texas Governor Greg Abbott, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, and Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds, has warned that immigrants are spreading throughout the United States. And that’s no wonder.

“Part of the problem is that the southern border is open, there are 88 countries that cross the border, they are not vaccinated because they do not have vaccines, and they are scattered all over the country.” Reynolds said In July.

“The elected civil servants are doing as much as Joe Biden’s open border policy to enable the spread of COVID in the United States,” said DeSantis. Fundraising August letter.

“The Biden administration has released South Texas immigrants who are exposing Texas to COVID. Some of those people were put on the bus and took their COVID to other states in the United States.” Abbott Told CNBC March.

There was a surge in new COVID-19 cases that began in mid-summer to late summer. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the number of new cases per day surged from about 12,000 in mid-June to about 160,000 in late August and early September. COVID data tracker.. At the same time, illegal immigrants are on the rise at the southwestern border, and concerns about illegal immigrants have skyrocketed from about 75,000 in January to more than 200,000 in July. data From US Customs and Border Protection.

But experts say the latter does not promote the former.

of Interview on October 3 Regarding CNN’s “program,” host Dana Bash asked Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute for Allergic Infectious Diseases, if the majority of Republicans surveyed by KFF had incorrect information. rice field.

“Is immigrants the main reason COVID-19 is so prevalent in the United States?” Bash asked.

“No, absolutely not, Dana,” Forch said. “That is, look at the data, look at the infected people, look at the people in the hospital, look at the people who died. This was not caused by immigrants. This is our country. It’s a problem, and it’s the same as in other countries around the world.

“That is, when 700,000 Americans have died and millions of Americans have been infected, we don’t want to look out of the question,” Fauci said. “The problem is in our country. Sure, immigrants can get infected, but they are not the driving force of this. Let’s face the reality here.”

Experts say the evidence is on Fauci’s side.

What the case data shows

according to CDC COVID TrackerVirtually all new cases emerging in the United States are caused by highly infectious delta mutations.

“I’ve never seen a phylogenetic signal that Delta arrived from Mexico or South America. In fact, the exact opposite. The most recent variant in the southern United States was the Delta-20B / 732A in Mexico until mid-May. , Peru, Argentina’s Gamma and Lamba, Chile, Brazil’s Gamma, Colombia’s Mu ” Emma Hodcroft, Postdoctoral fellow at the University of Bern, Switzerland, and co-developer of virus tracking site NextstrainSaid by email “And I have never seen these dominate in the United States, as immigrants with these variants are expected to be the main cause of the increase in incidents in the United States.”

Based on data from GISAID, an international open source repository of viral genomes, you can view a graph of variants that appear over time in different countries. website Created by Hodcroft. He called the popular concept of immigrants driving COVID-19 in the United States “harmful false alarms.”

“Instead, the increase in case numbers in the United States has a lot to do with Delta. Delta was first introduced from the United Kingdom and India, and perhaps from other countries throughout Europe, and soon afterwards from around the world. It spread relatively quickly because it is likely, “Hodocroft told us. “The Delta actually expanded to South America relatively late, probably because of much less close ties between Britain and India, and is very unlikely to be a source of Delta in the United States. is.”

Dr. Michele Heissler, The Medical Director of the Physicians for Human Rights and the Professor of Internal Medicine and Public Health at the University of Michigan agreed.

“As Dr. Forch emphasized, there is no epidemiological evidence that immigrants on the southern US border are promoting the spread of delta or earlier mutants that cause COVID-19,” Heissler said. I told us by email. “If you look at the hotspots of COVID-19 infection, they are all places with very low vaccination rates. That’s the lowest common denominator. Many of these hotspots are far from the border and immigrants It is in very few regions. In other areas on the border, such as the California-Mexico border, infection rates are not high. Epidemiological data also suggest that the delta variant spread to the United States before it spread to Mexico and Latin America. doing.”

As of October 8, California had only 16 new cases of coronavirus per 100,000 inhabitants reported in the last seven days, second only to Connecticut as the state with the lowest infection rate. according to NS New York Times’ COVID-19 mapping site.

Data from the Pan American Health Organization suggest that the spread of delta variants has come from the United States to Mexico, Heissler said.

Early July, American Association / American Council report: “The spread of delta variants to Latin America has been limited so far. Mexico is now experiencing itself. Increased transmissionHas the highest case load of variants identified in the region, with approximately 600 cases. This is probably because the variants are close to the rapidly expanding United States. “

Nevertheless largely Currently, of the COVID-19 cases in the United States, the delta variant is the cause and the CDC considers it a “variant of concern.” CDC too monitoring Number of Other variants At least in the United States Some of them Looks like you have Made their way To the United States through overseas travel, not immigrants.

According to Heissler, Americans pointing their fingers at immigrants who illegally cross the southwestern border are simply scapegoats.

“All reliable sources indicate the same cause. Low immunization rates are a major factor in the spread of the coronavirus,” Heissler said. “This is an unvaccinated pandemic, not a border issue, but a public health issue. Officials scapegoating COVID-19 asylum seekers identify foreign exclusion and immigrants as mediators of the disease. It accepts racially discriminatory language and ignores science. Instead, it should focus on improving vaccine intake and promoting common public health measures in the community. “

Status of McAllen, Texas

Nonetheless, the continued surge of immigrants at the southwestern border (thousands tested positive for COVID-19) warned, especially among some people living in the United States near the Mexican border. I am.

According to August 4th Press release From the city of McAllen, Texas, Catholic Charities and American Medical Response have identified more than 7,000 COVID-19-positive migrants brought into the city since mid-February (from a total of about 87,000 who passed through the city). ). Those who tested positive were isolated and quarantined, but authorities are worried about many unarrested migrants.

Most arrested migrants will soon be expelled under public health law, Title 42. Trump administration I started using it A March 2020 law expelling people at the border to prevent the spread of COVID-19. President Joe Biden continues to use it in a controversial manner, Battle in court To continue using the law. During the Trump administration, there were more than 444,000 people from March 2020 to January 2021 (more than 11 months). Title 42 Expulsion Located on the southwestern border.In the next 7 months (February to August) Over 690,000 For Biden’s watch.

NS Press release “The huge number of migrants released into the city is at stake,” says McAllen’s border city.

Maximum number of anxiety Manufactured in the Rio Grande sector, including McAllen in Hidalgo County.

Hidalgo County Officials, August 5 Press conference, He agreed that a surge in migrants at the border was at stake, but warned residents not to blame migrants for the county’s increasing number of COVID-19 cases.

Richard Cortez, Judge of Hidalgo County, a Democrat who is the highest elected official of the county, said: It’s not just true. “

He said that about 90% of people hospitalized for COVID-19 in Hidalgo County were not vaccinated.

“This is our own problem,” he said. “People don’t want to be vaccinated yet, so the number of COVIDs is increasing.”

At a press conference, Ivan Melendez, a public health official in Hidalgo County, said the increasing number of cases of COVID-19 in the county was no different than elsewhere in the country.

“Are the migrants part of the problem? Absolutely. The migrants are part of the problem. They are NS problem? No, “Melendez said.

Melendez pointed out the positive rate of immigrants, saying that “here it is almost exactly the positive rate.”

“Is this a pandemic of immigrants? No. It’s an unvaccinated pandemic,” Melendez said.

We spoke to Melendez on the phone, and he said, like other locals, he was dissatisfied with the federal government’s response to the surge in immigrants at the border.

“Of course, it will affect the locals,” he said. “I can’t deny it. There should be some impact. But are they the cause of the problem? Number.”

Immigrants make up about 3% of people hospitalized with COVID-19 in the county, “no new mutations along the border not found elsewhere in the United States,” he said.

“I keep hearing,’Without these immigrants, we wouldn’t have had this problem,'” Melendez said. “At the epicenter here, that’s not the case. It’s not the truth.”

Editor’s Note: SciCheck COVID-19 / Vaccination Project This is possible with a grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.Foundation has No control that’s all FactCheck.orgThe editorial decisions of, and the views expressed in our article, do not necessarily reflect the views of the Foundation. The goal of the project is to increase exposure to accurate information about COVID-19 and vaccines while reducing the impact of false information.

Migrants Not Responsible for Latest COVID-19 Surge Source link Migrants Not Responsible for Latest COVID-19 Surge

Back to top button